Skip to main

Best Pizza in Herkimer

A Taste of Herkimer’s Best with Unique Pizzas & More

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

The Netti's Pizza

Sausage, mushrooms, peppers, pepperoni & onions

Add Item

The Pile Driver Pizza (Large 16")

Double sausage, double pepperoni & double cheese

Add Item

The Netti's Pizza (Large 16")

Sausage, mushrooms, peppers, pepperoni & onions

Add Item

Fried Ravioli

Hand-breaded

Add Item

Large Antipasto Salad

Salami, provolone, onions, cucumbers, tomatoes, roasted peppers, banana peppers & Italian dressing

Add Item

Wings

Home of the original creamy western sauce. Approx. 6 large wings per lb

Add Item

Calzone

Includes mozzarella & sauce

Add Item

Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone Sub

Add Item

YettysBurg

1/2 Lb. Create your own burger

Add Item

Bacon Mushroom Swiss Burger

1/2 Lb. Bacon, mushrooms, onions & Swiss cheese

Add Item

Welcome to Yetty’s Pizza! 🍳

Welcome to Yetty’s Pizza! 🍳
Located in Herkimer, NY, Yetty's Pizza is the place to enjoy delicious pizzas, calzones, and Italian dishes. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or dining in with family and friends, we have something for everyone. We offer dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Stop by and see why we're a local favorite!

Local Eats You Can't Miss 🍕

Local Eats You Can't Miss 🍕
Looking to try something new? We’ve got the best local spots just around the corner. No need to travel far—authentic flavors are right at your doorstep. Let’s make your next meal one to remember!
Explore Our Menu

Dessert Time – The Perfect Finish 🍰

Dessert Time – The Perfect Finish 🍰
You’ve enjoyed your meal, now it's time to treat yourself! Our desserts are the sweet ending you deserve. From rich cakes to creamy treats, you’ll find the perfect way to top off your meal.
Order From Our Website 🖥️

Order From Our Website 🖥️

Skip the wait and order straight from our website! Get your favorite meals delivered right to your door or ready for pickup in no time. It’s fast, simple, and the easiest way to enjoy great food.
Order Now

📸 A Peek at Our Delicious Dishes

Check out some of our mouthwatering meals! Here’s a sneak peek of what you can expect when you visit or order from us. Each dish is crafted with care and made to bring joy to your table.

Easter Bread

Looking For A Private Events Space? 🍽️

Looking For A Private Events Space? 🍽️
We have a private event space that can host up to 25 people and provide a variety of food and beverage options. Please call Felicia at xxxxxxx
Get Your Catering Order Started

A Place for Everyone 🌸

A Place for Everyone 🌸
Whether you’re here for a relaxing meal or a fun night out, we’ve got you covered. Enjoy the fresh air with our outdoor seating, sip on some amazing cocktails, and let the little ones enjoy their own special menu. There's something for everyone!

Visit Us Today 😊

Yetty's Pizza is more than just a pizza spot – it’s a place where great food meets a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're here for our famous upside-down pizza or just a relaxed meal with friends, we’ve got the perfect setting for any occasion.

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Excellent food, good service and very clean. Can't wait to try other dishes.

Ivan H.

Ivan H.

Love this pizza. I grew up on this and always grab a pie when passing through. Unique way of making it.

Kathleen H.

Kathleen H.

Amazing food and friendly staff. Only end up getting Yetty's maybe twice a year but it's always top notch. Even highly recommended people I met in Ohio to go online and have some shipped to them since their idea of good pizza is Little Cesar's quality.

Matt B.

Matt B.

Featuring

Delivery

Takeout

Catering

Dine In

Has Outdoor Seating

Full Bar/Quick Draw

Has Kids' Menu

Yetty's Pizza Rewards

Yetty's Pizza Rewards

Get more out of every visit with our rewards program! Earn points every time you order from us, whether you’re dining in, picking up, or having your food delivered. Enjoy exclusive offers, discounts, and special treats as a thank-you for being a loyal customer. Sign up today and start earning rewards!

Frequently asked questions

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

We are located in Herkimer, NY at 109 Mohawk St

Our location